| Platinum | Leo's Coney Island |
| Gold | Plato's Place |
| Silver | Big Tommy's Parthenon |
| Bronze | Olga's Kitchen Laurel Park Place |
| Top Pick | Greek Islands Coney Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Koney Island Inn |
| Top Pick | Leda's Coney Island |
| Top Pick | Red Olive Northville |
| Cottage Inn Pizza |