| Platinum | Coaches Corner |
| Gold | Black Label Tavern |
| Silver | Thomas's Family Dining |
| Bronze | Amico's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Annie's Family Restaurant & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Archie's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Daly Drive-In |
| Top Pick | Leda's Coney Island |
| Top Pick | Mary's Grill |
| Top Pick | Senate Coney Island |
| Dave & Buster's |